Regard Humaniste
Des champignons, vénéneux ou non ?

A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami

Last edited: 16 Oct. 2026

100% Natural

100% natural! That is the great fashionable slogan among humans these days, the latest trend, the buzzword, for anyone wishing to attract customers.

From grocery stores to pharmacies, from laundry detergents to dietary supplements, to win over the consumer, there is no longer any need to demonstrate effectiveness, or to seek a fair price: one simply has to be natural.

It would seem that, from living so long in the comfort of your homes, humans, you have forgotten what Nature truly is. Nature is not a gentle nursemaid, it is not a friend who wishes you well. It is a merciless ecosystem, where for every relationship of symbiosis, one finds ten of predation. It is a Roman arena with no thumb ever raised in mercy, in which only the most violent, or the most fearful, survive. No plant, no animal, has ever had as its primary purpose doing good to humans. If you can sometimes benefit from their fruits, their extracts, their clothing fibers, it is purely a happy coincidence, a side effect of the single concern evolution has assigned to every species: survival.

Hence, if you go for a walk in the forest one of these days, and randomly eat whatever berries and mushrooms you come across, there is little chance you will enjoy a feast; but a good chance you will end up in the emergency room. Conversely, a great many entirely artificial materials have long been the pride of your households. Which would you rather own, a table made of plexiglass, or one made of living stinging nettles? Eat a mille-feuille flavored with artificial vanillin, or a smoothie of oleander seasoned with lily of the valley?

Life in general, and the human body in particular, are biological clockworks of extreme sensitivity, of outlandish complexity, in which the smallest grain of sand can have devastating effects (as endocrine disruptors bear witness). That is why nearly all the elements of the periodic table (lead, mercury, uranium…), and most of the molecules found in nature, are far more likely to derail your health than to strengthen it. And that is without even mentioning the correct dosage, without which even the most precious vitamins can turn into deadly poisons.

So, what is the point of all this excitement surrounding the Natural? In my view, it is quite simply a semantic misunderstanding, an intellectual bug. Humans confuse naturalness with harmlessness. If they were capable of even a modicum of rationality, they would not be seeking out whatever can be found in its natural state, as a result of the chances of biological evolution. They would be seeking out whatever is harmless; whatever has been tested, proven, through many years of rigorous trial steeped in scientific methodology. Whatever has known effects in the short and long term; at low and high doses; on fetuses as well as on adults; on humans as well as on the rest of the living world.

Humans confuse naturalness with harmlessness.

If it is a good idea, when you can afford it, to eat Organic, it is not simply to ape your ancestors, whose life expectancy did not reach half of yours. It is to guard (partially) against pesticides, chemical fertilizers, and other harmful substances, which continue to be poured onto farmland despite the repeated warnings of the scientific community. It is to preserve groundwater, bees, the fertility of your farmers, and more broadly to lower cancer rates among your populations. It is for a whole host of reasons. But surely not “because it’s more natural”. All the more so since the absence of preservatives comes at the cost of a greater propensity to rot, which is likewise rarely good for one’s health.

In the same way, the problem with GMOs is not the fact of modifying nature. You will someday have to be done with this Promethean superstition: if you listened to it, you would no longer use fire or electricity at all. Nature did not wait for humans before transforming and experimenting, sometimes on a positively dantesque scale - the dinosaurs could attest to that. The danger of GMOs is, first and foremost, the danger shared by all new chemical or biological products; that is why they must first be developed and tested in secure environments, for years, and later withdrawn from the market without delay if a health risk is discovered. Not to mention the issues tied to the “patentability of living things”; thus, in a crowning case of absurdity and injustice, some farmers have been ordered to pay royalties on neighboring GMO strains that had colonized their fields on their own. But when one knows that the lives of millions of children could be saved through a few genetic modifications to their staple food (wheat, rice…), making up for severe deficiencies in certain nutrients, one must hold a rather peculiar notion of morality to place the Sacredness of the Natural above all else.

Above all, do not forget: nearly all the fruits and vegetables found on your tables bear the imprint of human technology. They are the product of millennia of selective crossbreeding, aimed at increasing edible flesh, improving flavor, and getting rid of pits and seeds. Manipulations that are often far more brutal and random than the introduction of a single, well-identified gene. And I am not even mentioning the plump (but tragic) livestock animals, which no longer have much in common with their wild ancestors. That is why, in keeping with these technological advances, once a food product, even an entirely synthetic one, has been validated as safe (or even beneficial), I recommend you add it to your plate without the slightest displeasure.

Conversely, it is shocking to see how, as soon as a product proclaims itself natural, it gets exempted from even the most basic safety procedures. Essential oils, for instance (whose effectiveness, but also whose hazards, no longer need proving), come with precious little guidance on dosage, contraindications, or undesirable side effects. Compare that with the never-ending leaflets of your pharmaceutical medicines, even the most harmless ones, which detail their potential side effects down to the most infinitesimal probabilities.

Devotees of 100% natural also tend to forget that these industrial medicines, which they decry so loudly, are almost all derived from plants of the traditional pharmacopeia. The difference is that they isolate the active molecules, instead of forcing the patient to ingest them together with the whole mixture of nutrients, toxins, and waste of which they were originally part. It is, after all, rather convenient to be able to take an aspirin tablet, without having to chew on a willow bark for a long while. And it is hard to believe that “synthetic” molecules, identical down to the very atom to their natural counterparts, would behave any differently in the human body.

Let us give special mention to the growing rejection of “chemical medicines”. Yet, if one dislikes (organic) chemistry, the least one could do would be to stop all cooking and all digestion, which are thermal-enzymatic-acid-base-chemical reactions worthy of a full-blown industrial plant. Another oddity: those so quick to decry pharmaceutical companies for their greed fall remarkably silent when those very same companies sell costly homeopathic products that, statistically, do not contain a single molecule of active substance per ton of granules (as for the memory of water…).

There are many crucial issues within your industries.

  • Concerns about ecology, genetic diversity, and sustainable development.
  • Health-related and anti-allergenic concerns.
  • Ethical concerns (animal suffering, fair trade, fair competition).

What a pity, then, to keep gargling on about the “naturalness” of things, when even the color of the farmer’s shoes, or the age of the freight ship’s captain, have more relevance to the subject.

In the end, next time a merchant extols to you the virtues of his 100% natural product, ask him directly: is it natural like lettuce, or natural like a manchineel tree? And if it is natural like lettuce, do you not have more convincing arguments to put forward in promoting it?

To go further

See the associated logical fallacy, in English: Appeal to Nature

On GMOs, two very well documented articles: GMOs and Nature and GMOs and Dangers

Revision history

  • 2016/08/11: Removed the metaphor “an endless war without diplomacy” describing Nature, redundant with “a Roman arena with no thumb raised”
  • 2016/09/24: Rewrote the passage on GMOs, following further investigation
  • 2018/03/18: Trimmed the passage on homeopathic products
  • 2019/02/22: Spelling correction and addition of the “chemical medicines” paragraph
Tikami in wildlifeA glimpse of the author, the Tikami