Regard Humaniste
Une source de rivière dans la nature

A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami

Last edited: 16 Oct. 2026

The Source of Ethics

Humans are the “species of experts”, and each of you outclasses our little Tikami people on at least one subject, be it astronomy, cooking, pyrography, the long jump, whistling… But strangely enough, it is on the most important subjects that you show the greatest gaps. Thus, I have never managed to obtain a single satisfying answer to the most fundamental question there is: what is the source of Ethics?

Mind you, by this expression I do not mean the cause of ethical values and behaviors in living beings. Those traits have extremely multifactorial origins: upbringing, tradition, religion, empathy, reasoning, fear of the law, the pursuit of reputation, even instinct… No, what I am referring to is the foundation - if one exists - of the notions of Good and Evil. The sort of foundation that would allow us to treat them as objective and universal concepts, rather than subjective psychological phenomena, drifting along with cultural change.

Legalistic Moralities

Some people, without always admitting it, equate morality with legality. You will recognize them easily: they are the ones who, even in the middle of a debate about a legislative reform, will say without blinking, “Why shouldn’t we do that? Well, simply because that is illegal!”

It is difficult to escape this circular logic, in which laws are both the causes and the consequences of ethics. It is, however, easy to see the godsend that this way of thinking represents for any despot hoping to build a praetorian guard immune to conscientious objection.

Other people rely on arguments from Tradition. “We have always done it this way”, “It is a fundamental custom of our cultural identity”, and other heartfelt, but hardly convincing, arguments. This is in fact also a form of legalism, even though it appeals to customary law rather than formal law.

Transcendent Moralities

Some have answered me, categorically, that the source of morality was “God”. “Which one?” I asked. “Vishnu? Allah? Osiris? Ishtar? Yahweh? Christ? Odin?” “No, come now, the true God, So-and-so, of course! It is He and His Will that are Good, Light, and Truth, and everything else is nothing but Evil, Darkness, and Lies.” And I would be referred to a selection of truly Holy Books, in which the prescriptions and prohibitions to follow in order to remain on the side of Good were spelled out.

This approach strikes me as deeply problematic. Notwithstanding the sheer number of competing deities, one must also deal with conflicts of translation, of interpretation, of arbitration between canonical and apocryphal texts, not to mention the additions made by Tradition… Religions thus split into myriads of incompatible denominations, each brandishing armies of prophets, saints, and miracles to support its own exclusive legitimacy. The concepts of Good and Evil end up all the more battered for it.

But even if one accepts this additional quest - guessing which of these doctrines is right - the difficulties are only beginning. For, among the most forgotten gods as much as among the most popular ones, the moral system on offer is a fine old shambles. Dietary directives get mixed up with boasting and unverifiable promises, the most useful questions remain unanswered, and from failing to ever condemn dubious practices such as slavery or stoning, the mystics end up promoting them instead. I am quite willing to accept that humanity works a little differently from my Tikami people, but really now, even exotic customs have their limits.

“If God does not exist, then everything is permitted” some preachers like to say. A terrifying morality indeed, one that is upheld only by the Carrot and the Stick of a Supernatural Entity whose very existence remains an open question.

Philosophical Moralities

Many of your philosophers have distanced themselves from this religious morality, and conceptualized various ethical systems. Take, for instance, the famous Kant. I confess I have not dug very deep into his reasoning, nor identified any precise “source” for his ethics; there was talk of “treating others as an end and not a means”, or “acting in a way that could become a universal maxim”. This rejection of Vol’Res seemed to me a good omen.

But in practice, this led to categorical commandments such as “never lie”. In other words, to secular equivalents of the worst that exists in the world of religious beliefs: Dogmas.

These tyrannical directives, incapable of adapting to the context of reality, incapable of accounting for dilemmas, bear in my view no family resemblance whatsoever to the ethics that humanity actually needs. One need only read Kant calling for handing one’s neighbor over to criminals for the sake of honesty, to be convinced of this.

Other philosophers, fortunately, took a more measured approach to the problem. They acknowledged the limits of ready-made maxims, weighed both the motivations and the consequences of words and deeds, paraphrased the famous Golden Rule that everyone is more or less aware of… but the instructions drawn from these reflections are, once again, only the consequences of the ethical source, not its essence. And when one builds ethics without a solid foundation, one easily falls into traps such as moral relativism (e.g. everyone decides for themselves what is good or bad), or a fascist ethics (e.g. the weak must disappear so that - the ultimate concern - humanity may be strong and efficient).

Not having enough human culture to point you toward any happy predecessors in this field, I will therefore share with you the source that we Tikami have identified for a lasting and just ethics.

The Empirical Source

Could you tell me, dear reader, why it is harmless to drop a pebble onto the sand of a beach, but not onto the head of a beachgoer? Why you enjoy kicking a ball, but not stubbing your little toe against a shelf? Why you fearlessly trim your hedges and lawns, but not your ears and teeth? Why you may freely threaten and curse at your broken-down car, but not at the mechanic or the insurance agent?

The answer is simple: because of sentience.

It may be physical sentience (carried by the sensory nerves), or psychic sentience (emotions and feelings, born from information received and transformed by brain activity). The two are, of course, interdependent (somatization on one side, psychic impact on the other).

It may be a sentience in its actuality (e.g. for you, reading these lines), or in its potentiality (even a person in deep sleep must not be killed, since they will, in principle, wake up again one day).

This capacity to have positive and negative sensations is, as far as I know, the one, necessary, and sufficient source of ethics. Some have additionally invoked “self-awareness”. It is difficult for us to imagine a sentience entirely devoid of this self-awareness; but what I am convinced of is that even the most immature of babies, unable to find its own thumb, incapable of recognizing itself in a mirror, in near-fusion with its mother’s breast, deserves to be respected every bit as much as the metaphysical thinker it will become a few years later. Let us content ourselves, then, with this commonly experienced notion: the fact of feeling things.

It is from this sentience of beings that the notions of Happiness and Unhappiness arise, along with the paths leading to them, namely Good and Evil. Without it, there is no more “what I want done unto me”, there is no more Golden Rule. In the cosmos, stars are born and die in infinite peace. And the same would hold true for you, if you were pure biological clockwork: either devoid of any awareness of phenomena, or utterly insensitive to their effects (“in good shape or completely broken? alive or dead? I couldn’t care less”).

Where the Shoe Pinches

Positing sentience as the universal source of ethics is, for humans, both pleasant and unsettling “news”. Pleasant, because everyone has such an intimate experience of this shared sentience that it takes only a smidgen of logic to work out, on one’s own, the great principles of a universal ethics. Unsettling, because in this definition there is no question of divinity, species, or race; and so this ethics protects all sentient beings, whether human or animal, earthly or extraterrestrial, natural or (let us grant it) supernatural.

Aware that causing suffering was morally questionable, but that it was rather convenient to shamelessly exploit animals, humans have often fought hard to deny them any sentience. Descartes rambled on about the animal-machine, which of course only mimicked suffering when beaten or slaughtered. Enthusiasts have piled up arguments and pseudo-studies to prove that bullfighting bulls feel no pain while their flesh is being carved up (because they produce painkillers, just like women giving birth, QED). Fishermen have kept alive the myth that lobsters have no sensation of pain, which studies on crustaceans have done anything but confirm. And this denialist tendency has even spilled over onto humans themselves, with the promoters of children’s boxing matches in Asia telling anyone who will listen that “they love them like their own sons, and besides, it doesn’t hurt”.

It is, in truth, a great tragedy that humans are not able to “sense” the sentience of others, as we Tikami do. This super-empathy would have prevented a good many quiet cruelties. It would also have allowed you to probe, and surely dismiss, the more daring theories: plant consciousness, panpsychism, Gaia theories… It would have helped assess, in a way both kind and fair, the dignity owed to every living being, from humans down to gut bacteria. But as long as you lack this sense, you will have to fall back on observation, empathy, and one of the rarest commodities on Earth: intellectual honesty.

Recognizing that sentience is the origin of ethics is, alas, no magic recipe: to derive from it a moral system that is both complete and beneficial, generous doses of Reason and Empathy are also required. For besides the ease with which people deny the sentience of others, serious pitfalls still remain to be avoided, such as pure deontologism (“consequences don’t matter as long as I mean to do people Good”), or pure utilitarianism (“let us sacrifice this innocent so that his organs may save three others from serious illness”). And I am not even mentioning the countless more or less imaginary dilemmas, over which generations of moralists have never stopped debating. But let us be realistic: most of the conflicts you encounter are disconcertingly easy to resolve, as long as one takes “respect for sentient beings” as one’s compass, rather than one of the thousand and one ideological chimeras that try to steal the show from it.

Revision history

  • 2016/10/28: Reordering of the paragraphs in “The Empirical Source”
  • 2016/11/02: Addition of the notions of Reason and Empathy in the conclusion
  • 2016/11/05: Vocabulary simplifications and punctuation adjustments
  • 2016/11/13: Clarification of the phrase “source of ethics”
  • 2018/08/05: Fixed a French wording slip (“par contre” -> “en revanche” in the original), added a link about the Golden Rule
Tikami in wildlifeA glimpse of the author, the Tikami