A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami
One day, I was compelled to attend, alongside my host, a lecture on “the formal requirements for intra- and extra-Community VAT declarations under French law.” For an effervescent, artistic soul such as mine, I need hardly say that each second crawled by like a dozen eternities. Until a certain Gentleman grew heated, and took the lecturer to task…
“So, let me get this straight, I’m supposed to write my supplier’s VAT number on my invoices!? But that’s snitching, that is!”, he hammered.
I took away two things from that outburst. First, that this Gentleman considered it perfectly proper to defraud his country’s tax authorities, and to help others do likewise; a point I shall not dwell upon. Second, that snitching was, in his eyes, an utterly pejorative notion.
Lending an ear to what was being said around me, I soon realized he was not alone in holding a poor opinion of snitching. “I don’t like snitches,” a public figure likewise declared on some polemical talk show.
Now, it seems to me that not only is “snitching” an idea that has been badly misused, but that, even in its canonical definition, it is far from being entirely at odds with a just society.
Indeed, what is the antonymic lexical field of snitching? It is omertà, the law of silence; it is complicity, compromise, indulgence toward crime. A society that prefers these principles to snitching is a society of impunity, in which victims find themselves defenseless against the lies, concealments, and stagings of oppressors, the violent, and the corrupt of every stripe. That is not the society any person of good will would wish for. Conversely, what terms are linked to snitching? Testimony, the denunciation of injustice, whistleblowing. Notions with a far less pejorative connotation. Could it be that snitching, in reality, belongs to that countless family of positive concepts which, under pressure from dishonest minds, have ended up tarnished with disgrace?
Not quite, for as the attentive reader will have noticed, there exists a notable semantic distinction between reporting and snitching. The latter would be, according to the Larousse dictionary, “a self-interested, contemptible act of reporting, inspired by vengeance, jealousy, or greed”. Here one senses a point of friction: when motives are sordid, actions stand a good chance of becoming so too, and reports of becoming fallacious or biased. But what should we make of it, if a given act of snitching is justified in every respect except for the motives of the denouncer-turned-snitch? For a follower of deontological ethics, who cares more about human motives than about the effects of human actions, this is indefensible; but for pragmatic, well-meaning consequentialists such as ourselves, it is not of prime importance: better a crime exposed by a neighbor’s jealousy than one concealed by his friendship.
However, this « academic » distinction is not the one the general public has in mind. When one digs a little into the darkness surrounding this word “snitching”, one quickly lands – let us embrace the cliché wholeheartedly – upon the darkest hours of human history. The era when everyone handed their Jewish, homosexual, or otherwise Aryan-undesirable neighbors over to the executioners. What no one seems to realize is that this is not really snitching at all. Indeed, “reporting an innocent person” is an expression that escapes the grip of all rationality. What a sad irony that, confusion piling upon confusion, snitching should thus have ended up conflated with one of its greatest opposites, namely complicity in crimes against humanity; in the same way that citizens cooperating with the police and the justice system, which goes without saying in a society at peace, has remained tainted by the era of collaborators and Kafkaesque political trials. Some will say that these “informers” genuinely believed they were striking at Agents of the Enemy, and that is quite probably true, but this points to a far more general problem: within an ideological system whose axioms are false, reasoning no longer matters, motives no longer matter, the meaning of words no longer matters, since the world of ideas and reality have divorced one another; it is therefore unfortunate that the terms remain so marked by the collective delusions of the past, long after the ideology in question has run out of steam.
But in any case, when one hears people railing against snitches, it is typically neither the informer’s moral elevation, nor even this notion of collusion with a criminal system, that is truly at stake. Those thus consigned to infamy are the people who dare to lift the veil on the doings of schemers, fraudsters, thieves, manipulators, persecutors, and racketeers of every description… those who dare, in the end, to help Justice along, whether out of civic duty (which would be best), or for the sheer pleasure of stirring up the muck (which would still be better than nothing).
Does that mean reporting is beneficial on every occasion? No, because beyond the possible existence of moral dilemmas (should one report a thief, knowing that the jurisdiction in question is liable to torture him?), excessive snitching runs afoul of the principle of subsidiarity. It is useless, even harmful, to appeal to higher authorities, to give wide publicity to a dispute, if the matter can be settled amicably, on a smaller scale; whether between the parties themselves, or with the help of a simple mediator. Some schools accordingly vie with one another in teaching their young saplings to tell useful reports (vandalism, intimidation, extortion…) apart from those that merely sow discord over trifles (“Miss, Jules stuck his tongue out at me!!!”). And one may reasonably think that, upon catching some scamp spray-painting one’s garage door, it is wiser to make him clean it all up himself than to ask the judicial authorities to come poking their great paws into the matter.
That it is better to be a denouncer of injustice than a snitch ought to be beyond dispute. That it is not necessarily all that useful to restore the true meaning of the word “snitching”, blurred as it has been by History, when we have far more pleasant synonyms at our disposal, is an idea that strikes me as equally defensible.
On the other hand, dear reader, I urge you to plant this little alarm bell in your mind: the next time you hear someone rail against snitching, ask yourself whether it is mere deontological posturing, or whether that person simply fears seeing one of their own compromising — or even criminally punishable — secrets dragged out of the shadows.