A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami
There exists an omnipresent commonplace belief among the good citizens of the world. It proclaims, in order to avoid tyranny, the necessity of separating three powers: legislative, executive, and judicial.
I confess that this thesis leaves me rather puzzled. The executive is supposed to apply the laws defined by the legislature, and the judiciary is supposed to punish those who have violated them. If they were to rebel against their legislative mentor, refuse to take certain laws into account, or invent their own, that would not look like a check on power; rather like the beginnings of civil war, a perilous path for individual liberties if ever there was one. The political paralyses experienced in France under the Directory (1795-1799) or the Second Republic (1848-1852) led, if the historians are to be believed, to the downfall of those institutions.
And what on earth does “separating” these powers even mean? If the country is governed by a triumvirate of consuls, each monopolizing one of these three competencies, I find it hard to believe that the situation would be balanced from the common people’s point of view; I would fear far less a large assembly claiming all three prerogatives for itself, provided it were made up of citizens chosen by lot.
Let us be clear, these three aspects of political power are in fact meant to act in harmony with one another. It is the legitimacy of each of them, the constitutional safeguards, and the democratic processes, that will determine whether the people are protected from their abuses.
That said, in my own universe, we too have a Proverb of the Three Powers.
But it concerns the powers of “politics, media, and finance”.
For it is indeed they who determine the destiny of a nation, by granting to one or another of its members authority, fame, or wealth.
This is why our ancestral wisdom forbids us from gathering these three sources of power into the same hands. And why we do not understand, dear human friends, how you can tolerate this proliferation of authoritarian politicians, filthy rich, who spread their sophistries and fake news through newspapers at their beck and call and cacophonous social networks. If your political representatives had to work for the country’s average wage, and maintain at all times the demeanor of discreet and diligent civil servants, the candidates for these positions would doubtless be of far less deplorable quality.