A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami
There exist, in the human mind, many brakes upon change. Some are legitimate: caution in the face of risks of public-health catastrophe, economic destabilization, ethical regression… Others are rather more suspect: defense of tradition, adherence to dogma, a principled rejection of scientific progress (obscurantism)…
But there exists a psychological block just as widespread as it is comical, and of which nobody speaks. Finding no dedicated terminology for it, I have named it: the fear of disappearance through de-necessitation. Allow me to explain.
My host was one day waxing enthusiastic, to perfect strangers met on the fringes of a wedding, about the emergence of self-driving cars, thanks to which he could spend his travel time on far more constructive pursuits than monitoring his position, speed, and acceleration over time. His enthusiasm was not shared. His interlocutors, on the contrary, grew quite distressed: it would be dreadful if cars became automatic; they themselves loved to drive, to be in control of their vehicle, and if things kept going this way, they would eventually no longer be able to. They also raised the risk of accidents caused by software bugs.
I shall not dwell overlong on the second point. If one compares the cognitive and computational abilities of a machine — capable of analyzing and memorizing hundreds of indicators within nanoseconds — with those of a human, known for an attention span and a reaction time worthy of a clam, one understands this Tikami saying rather better: “a human is as well suited to the controls of an automobile as a chimpanzee is to those of a bulldozer”. All the more so since a driving program can be tested, “debugged” as you say, so as to make it ever more reliable. This cannot be said of the few billion bipeds who delight in mixing speeding, phone calls, alcohol, and other drugs.
The fear expressed in the first point, however, deserves an answer, and even a rebuttal. Less through logical arguments than empirical ones. For if there is one thing your millennia of history ought to have taught you, human friends, it is that necessity is far from being a prerequisite for the existence of your activities. Examples follow.
This process of transformation, through which a former necessity becomes a new leisure while gaining degrees of freedom, I have called “playification”; or, for those who prefer their roots Hellenistic, “eutrapelization”. Let us now apply this lesson from the past to the concerns of the future.
What will happen if self-driving cars become the norm? Most people will use them as personal taxis, racing along at speed with unparalleled levels of safety and predictability. Whenever a road accident occurs, it will make the national headlines. If the technology proves sufficient to make up for the vagaries of Homo-Sapiens-not-always-Sapiens drivers, manual and automated cars will coexist. Otherwise, those who love driving will go about their pastime on separate lanes, or on bucolic country roads. The market for racetracks will likely boom, offering aficionados, depending on taste, either tracks delivering dizzying sensations of speed or cleverly designed obstacle courses. One way or another, playification will run its course; but nothing supports the fearful hypothesis that the spread of automated driving would bring about the disappearance of manual driving. By separating transportation from the pleasure of driving, humanity will simply be optimizing the scant amount of life-time each individual has at their disposal.
Another case. There exist experimental foods such as « Soylent », which attempt to provide you with every nutrient you need, without recourse to dangerous products or the persecution of animals, and at a lower ecological cost. If you bring up this subject in public, you will probably be met with a heartfelt protest: « but then there will be no more gastronomic pleasure, no more conviviality, no more family meals ». Then you will have to endure a litany of every dystopian novel in which dehumanized individuals, stripped of all pleasure, toil day and night for a totalitarian system, surviving on nothing but pouches of liquid for every meal; a charming thing, demonstration by fiction. What does the History of playification teach us? That if present-day meals serve a social function, are a shared pleasure, or simply a personal one, they will continue to exist; to delight gourmets, to bring families and friends together. Artificial foods will chiefly serve to replace the snacks eaten on the run, often in defiance of the most basic dietary rules. Perhaps, standing as they do at the junction of gastronomy and chemistry, these concoctions will even allow themselves to recreate flavors forgotten for millennia, delighting a few taste buds long dormant at the back of your palates. But by separating nutritional balance from gustatory pleasure, humanity will gain a degree of freedom, one more lever of action toward being « mens sana in corpore sano ».
In short, human friends, do stop fearing that advances — scientific progress in particular — will strip you of the pleasures you hold dear. If humanity finds something pleasant, its ceasing to be necessary will in no way mean its annihilation. On the contrary, it will free that pleasure from the obligations that bound it, and improve it. To finish convincing you, take a look inside your shopping carts, your cupboards, your schedules; you will likely realize that the superfluous, whether beneficial or harmful, there often outweighs the indispensable. And next time you see a human throw a fit of technophobia, prophesying the disappearance of their favorite activity because of scientific progress, seize the occasion to explain to them the concept of playification/eutrapelization.
Revision history