A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami
The Tikami: I shall presently hand over the floor, or rather the pen, to a French citizen who is a tad exasperated.
If you are a European citizen, your email inbox was inevitably besieged, back in May 2018, by dozens of automated emails; missives announcing an “update to the terms of service” of all sorts of various services, some of which you had practically forgotten even existed. Banks, insurers, shops, social networks, every company grew enthusiastic about “wanting to help you control your personal data”, in other words about complying with the new GDPR regulation.
Now, the question that arises is: did you read those emails, and the documentation they linked to? No? Unsurprising. That is anticipated and fully accepted by the services in question. For this is merely yet another avatar of what should rightly be called the “Terms of Service Scam”.
You know those little pop-up windows with 20 pages of impenetrable legal verbiage, blocking your way whenever you want to install a program? Or those “general terms of sale”, and other “legal notices”, lurking in the margins of your favorite websites’ forms? Do you read them every single time? Every other time? Have you ever read even a single one all the way through? How unfortunate. For by clicking the “I agree” button, by browsing the website, or by continuing to use the service, you are sealing a contract with the legal entity behind it. You are accepting its clauses, the rights and duties binding both parties, to the broad extent that these are not themselves illegal.
Why do you do it? Were you never taught that before signing a contract, you ought to have read, understood, and approved it in full? Does it not bother you to sign blank checks like this, handing them to third parties who will plunder and resell your personal data, decide on commitment periods and cancellation fees, quibble over what is included or excluded from warranties, limit their liability at the drop of a hat, and all according to rules that they alone have unilaterally specified?
In truth, this is not a free and informed choice on your part. It is a stopgap, a desertion. Because you have neither the time nor the motivation to read the thousands of pages that these terms of service amount to. Because you likely have no ease at all in deciphering certain obscure jargon, sometimes written only in English, which specialized lawyers spent weeks polishing. Because you do not have the years of legal training needed to distinguish lawful clauses from unlawful ones, those whose ambiguity can lead to abuse from those that merely restate your country’s own laws. Because, on top of being soporific, this legalistic paperwork does nothing but paraphrase, in a thousand different ways, the very same handful of ideas, carefully drowning within them their least admissible local variations.
Now, let us assume you are someone extremely diligent, well-educated, and with time to spare. You have read them. All of them. You have even made timestamped and sorted copies, deposited with your bailiff in case of future litigation. You have thus earned the elitist privilege of pressing the famous approval buttons in full conscience and good faith. What happens next?
Suuuurpriiise! Terms of service, updated.
And not only for the grand “GDPR” legal cavalcade mentioned above; it happens all the time, in a more diffuse, more random, more obscure manner.
And it never stops; the smallest tweak to a service, the most insignificant of a mobile app’s several-times-a-month updates, can be a pretext to display a fresh cascade of contractual diarrhea, accompanied by the hypocritical “I have read, understood, and accept” button. However valiant you may be, how many hours are you prepared to sacrifice each month just to keep your record of these “ToS” up to date?
A minority of services make an effort. In a foreword, they recap for the user the changes that have taken place, along with their motivations. But be warned, they never once swear to have produced an exhaustive summary; nothing obliges them to, for that matter; do you still feel like signing them this blank check, along the lines of “I hope your summary is faithful enough that I will not regret it”? Or will you push your devotion so far as to compare this recap against the two mountains of prose it supposedly represents, namely the current and previous terms of service?
And that is not all. Even if you were to read everything that lands on your desk… what happens if you disagree? It is not as though you had the slightest room for negotiation. The terms of service are a hefty slab, take it or leave it. And between the “network effects” of social and professional apps, the tacit agreements among Telecom giants, the monopolies granted through patents or artistic exclusivities, and the sheer proliferation of practices detrimental to consumers, you rarely have any choice at all.
If a sock vendor claims, in its terms of sale, the right to help itself to your refrigerator as it pleases, you can always say “confound it, I shall buy my clothes elsewhere”. But will you abandon your friends, or your community of fellow customers, present on Facebook, just to avoid having your data vampirized? Will you resell that phone you recently bought for over 400€, when, on its very first start-up, it grants itself the right to ship your personal information halfway across the world? Will you go without a bank until you find one that does not crush its most destitute customers under hundreds of euros in overdraft fees? If so, I grant you my highest esteem. But the rest of humanity cannot always afford such strength of conviction.
Of course, there are a few exceptions to the rule. If you check or uncheck - it depends on the question - the dozens of boxes in Google’s user preferences, on every single computer and browser you use, you can (theoretically, at least) escape a good deal of their surveillance. If you always watch out for the “I wish to receive offers from partners” checkboxes slyly hidden (and pre-ticked) within sign-up forms, you can escape massive waves of spam. But the irony of it all is that your vigilance must never falter; whereas for them, a single slip on your part is all it takes.
In summary: “terms of service”, as currently practiced across the board, are a gigantic farce, blending abuse of power with a paperwork harassment akin to a Gish Gallop. Even citizen-led attempts to tame them (e.g. Terms Of Service, Didn’t Read) only amount to bailing out the ocean with a bucket. This denial of democracy and justice, which undermines the very notion of a contract between businesses and individuals, must end. How? See below for an example of an alternative system.
Illustration: Dima Yarovinsky printed out the entirety of the terms of service of major online services for his work "I agree".
...an average person can read 200 words per minute, whereas terms of service average 11,972 words. That means it would take 60 minutes to read them in full...
Dear companies, fond of paperwork deluges…
This information either goes without saying, or reflects a paranoia woven from centuries of absurd case law (for judges seem in no hurry at all to crack down on “abuse of rights” and other schemes by dishonest customers or competitors); this is information that the average citizen should not have to swallow in a thousand different versions.
It deserves to be carved in stone, once and for all, into Standard Terms of Service; one per business sector: banking, insurance, online retail, file-hosting services, professional social networks… A hierarchy of documents pooling this shared information, compiling the customary norms of each sector, distinguishing what is legally required from what falls under commercial freedom, and above all systematically ruling in favor of the consumer whenever practices diverge.
This is where the first innovation of the system comes in: companies may still propose their own Terms of Service; but in the form of a VERSIONED DIFFERENTIAL DOCUMENT; meaning only the passages added, modified, or removed relative to the standard document (to which reference is of course made); the whole thing enhanced with an automatic display of how this differential has evolved over time. All of this has existed for a long time in the field of software development, and should already make things far clearer, while bringing the schemes of overzealous lawyers back up to the surface. Here is a small example of such a differential, on the versioned repository of the French Civil Code.
A second safeguard is nonetheless necessary, to counter the petty temptation of producing a “differential” even more verbose than the original document. The SYNTHETIC PREFACE: a text summarizing, within a limited format (e.g. a maximum of 10 paragraphs and 800 words, displayed in at least 14-point font), everything that may be particularly favorable or contentious within that service’s own Terms of Service, along with the main risks involved in that type of offering.
Indeed, just about anyone can ramble on for pages and pages of dense text. What is far harder, on the contrary, is to simplify and synthesize: “I am writing you a long letter because I do not have time to write a short one”, as Blaise Pascal once said. Let it now be the lawyers who take on this pruning effort, not innocent consumers; that is how it should always have been.
This will put an end to the unhealthy reign of “fine print clauses” and “implicit risks”. If a non-standard clause unfavorable to the user is not reflected in this summary, it will be deemed null and void. Likewise, the company will bear the damages if the user was not properly warned of the risks specific to a service: over-indebtedness through currency devaluation in the case of a loan taken out in a foreign currency, a collision with an uninsured driver if the user does not take out comprehensive car insurance, the near-impossibility of removing from the Web content that has been publicly posted there (among other reasons, because of a certain Streisand Effect)…
And then, you will ask me, what if the company is unable to sum up its service’s flaws on this half a page? Then it will have to rework the service itself until it can. You cannot imagine the solutions that can emerge once businesses are no longer incentivized to wear down and swindle their customers, but to respect them instead.
All very nice, you will say, but this differential and synthetic approach will not stop a business from openly, serenely, pulling the wool over its customers’ eyes. The duty to inform has already been imposed many times in the past, without changing much; thanks to our thoughtful European Union technocrats, cumbersome banners now warn you that by entering a given website, you consent to being spied on with every click; the new GDPR piled on yet another layer; and smartphone apps now automatically display the permissions they require (access to contacts, location, photos…) upon installation. In the end, the ordinary consumer simply has more and more warning windows to click through, more and more information to skim over, with no real bargaining power at all.
The main benefit of these summaries will therefore be the awareness that their very exposure will inevitably stir up. The last - and hardest - step will then remain to be taken: pruning, through a vigorous effort of democratic regulation, the innumerable abuses that have become the norm in every single trade.
No, your “tracking cookies” are not in the least meant to “improve the user experience”. Only to plunder users’ private lives (resold to third parties), to bombard them with increasingly intrusive advertising, to steal their brain time, and then to bill them back for this whole Marketing&Manipulation mess within the price of the final product.
No, your endless notice periods for cancellation, your costly service-termination fees, correspond to no technical necessity whatsoever. They are nothing but abuses of a dominant position - a large company against an isolated individual - meant to chain that individual down and make them pay for services against their will, the moment they commit the slightest lapse of attention as a deadline approaches.
What will therefore be needed is a joint mobilization of lawmakers, consumer advocacy groups, and dedicated regulatory inspectors, in order to reaffirm and enforce certain fundamental principles of a society that claims to be civilized: no private interest should ever be allowed to override the general interest; any clause introducing an imbalance between the rights of the company and those of the consumer, without any real and serious justification, is null and void; just like the human body, privacy belongs among those things that cannot be bought or sold… etc.
In their mythology, the Greeks made one and the same god, Hermes, the patron of both merchants and thieves. The digital age has poisoned this collusion further still, adding to it the mass surveillance of private life, and a deluge of legalistic prose. A legislative offensive is needed to reverse this trend, and to give consumers back a measure of consideration within the planetary economic jungle. “Simplification shocks” such as differential and synthetic terms of service, along with many other measures yet to be invented, will be necessary for this effort to be more than just another damp squib, and instead become a deep change in the rules of the game. Companies, too, stand to gain from this change, for the system of petty abusive clauses is a double-edged sword.