Regard Humaniste
Manifestation pour le Droit du TravailCredits: Gotta Be Worth It via Pexels

A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami

Last edited: 16 Oct. 2026

The Right to Strike, A Strange Archaism

The Tikami: I shall presently hand over the floor, or rather the pen, to a French citizen who is a tad exasperated.

We are glad, in France, to have the right to strike. Is it not the bare minimum, after all, to be able to suspend one’s labor for a company, when its executives, pressed by insatiable shareholders, overstep the bounds of sound management?

Yes, indeed it is. The bare minimum. The right to strike is to labor law what moonshine is to pre-operative anesthesia; a rudimentary, even dangerous, palliative; but coated, moreover, with a hefty dose of injustice.

A Highly Uneven Effectiveness

When it is public transit, or water or electricity distribution, that is thrown into turmoil, what an uproar in the press and among the population. But when it is a small industrial or service company, subject to fierce competition, it will get, at most, a small notice in the newspaper.

“At least the company in question is affected by the strike”, you say? Often, yes; but not always. Perhaps it has stock to clear out. Perhaps it was precisely dreaming of forcing employees to accept partial unemployment. Perhaps it has far too much to gain, in the long run, from “trimming the fat off its payroll” (dreadful metaphor), even if that means several months of lost revenue.

But while a strike is barely effective in some trades, in others it is, paradoxically, far too effective. If garbage collectors go on strike, within a few weeks the sanitary situation can become highly dangerous. If police officers go on strike, a sharp spike in crime is to be expected. If hospital staff go on strike, you may as well say your goodbyes to loved ones waiting in the emergency room corridors. As for strikes among nuclear power plant staff, I would rather not think about it. This is why, faced with this disproportionate power, these endangerments of other people’s lives, some workers find themselves forced to formally declare themselves on strike (and lose their pay) while continuing to work all the same; whereas employees in sovereign state functions (the Army, the Police, the Judiciary…) are, in France, purely and simply deprived of this right to strike; a touch farcical, is it not?

And devising a strike that is both effective and does not endanger others is not the whole story. One must also be able to afford it. Have you noticed that the companies most prone to strikes seem far from being those where working conditions are the most unfavorable? When one barely earns minimum wage and ends up in the red at the end of every month, one thinks ten times over before heading into several days, several weeks, of lost pay (even counting on financial solidarity among strikers). In a company with highly favorable wages and collective agreements, striking is far less costly; taken to the extreme, it could even become a company tradition, aimed at “flexing one’s muscles in front of management” rather than a genuine outburst of frustration.

Note that in certain sectors (e.g. air travel), it is enough for employees to strike for just one hour a day to bring the entire service to a halt for extended periods, at the cost of very limited pay losses; is that not, in a way, somewhat unfair?

To top it all off, it sometimes happens that a company is genuinely in financial trouble, not merely running an accounting deficit thanks to clever strategic maneuvers; and the strike finishes off discouraging its last remaining clients. A fine remedy indeed, one that turns out worse than the disease.

A Transitive Oppression

Who is harmed, when rail services are paralyzed or thrown into disarray by a strike? The political leaders, who travel comfortably by chauffeured car, or by plane even when the train would be faster? Or the average French citizen, who has next to no control over the ideological whims of elected officials and their retinue of lobbyists?

A social movement usually seeks to win the solidarity of the whole population, in order to carry more weight. But is that really how one stirs up compassion in one’s fellow citizens? By trampling over their vacations, their professional appointments, their daily lives? Is there not a strong risk that this proves highly counter-productive, especially if the reasons for the strike are not sufficiently publicized and understood by public opinion?

In many companies, the strike thus perpetuates what one might call transitive oppression, a strategy that leads suffering humans to take innocent bystanders hostage and mistreat them, for lack of any hold whatsoever over those actually responsible for their woes. Does that ring any bells?

What Alternative Solution?

“Criticism is easy, art is difficult”, you will tell me. What system should we propose in place of this defective right to strike?

In theory, we have hundreds of generously paid parliamentarians whose job it is to reflect on, among other things, modernizing the social balance of power. But there you go: a government that spends so much energy lightening the tax burden on the wealthy, policing the unemployed, and carving up public services probably has neither the time nor the inclination to tackle this particular project.

Let us imagine, then. What would a “right to strike, version 2” look like? Here is a sketch of such a Right to Strikage, generalizing systems that already exist here and there.

When an employee goes on strikage, they must continue their work with the usual diligence. But they lose a percentage X of that day’s pay. The company, meanwhile, is slapped by the State with a fine corresponding to a percentage Y of its daily revenue. X and Y are variables that can depend on a multitude of factors, including of course the aforementioned wage and revenue. Variables determined by the legislature, out of concern for fairness between different trades, and balance between the powers of employers and unions; which of course requires a genuinely representative democracy, without which this very debate would itself be enough to trigger massive strikes… but that is another matter.

Note that instead of penalizing GDP, through its freeze on productivity and the attendant disruptions, this strikage would generate a financial windfall that could be put to good use.

The old right to strike would then only remain in a few very particular cases, for example:

  • as a Right to Withdraw, when working conditions no longer guarantee the physical and psychological safety of employees;
  • when fining is ineffective, for instance if the company belongs to the State;
  • when the very goal is to block production, paralyze the country, and escalate into a general strike, in order to challenge the economic system as a whole;

In a world where technological, scientific, and cultural developments unfold at such a breakneck pace, one cannot be satisfied with a political and social system that, for its part, remains stuck in the Stone Age. Granted, the current right to strike, which impoverishes the poorest and turns citizens against one another, does not exactly displease those in power; its replacement will therefore not happen tomorrow. But let that not stop us from rising above our role as “good little sheep waiting for the next election”, and from spreading the word, so that the distressing obsolescence of this system may at least become the subject of a collective awakening.

Tikami in wildlifeA glimpse of the author, the Tikami