Regard Humaniste
Un homme croise les doigts pour avoir de la chance.

A philosophical essay by the sweet Tikami

Last edited: 16 Oct. 2026

On Respecting Beliefs

It seems to me that you humans are, at times, far more attached to political correctness than to the flourishing of your fellow creatures. Thus, as soon as some particularly religious season begins, with its straitjacket of more or less justifiable prescriptions and proscriptions, everyone rolls out the red carpet for it, proclaiming that “here, we respect all beliefs”. Zealots of every stripe take advantage of these soothing declarations to keep extending their demands further and further; to the point of crying offense the moment some passer-by dares, in merely voicing his own thoughts, to contradict them. And yet, in your universe, it seems obvious to me that dignity is inherent to PERSONS, not to IDEAS. Allow me to explain.

The Power of Ideas

Sentient beings - humans among them - possess an intrinsic respectability, untouched by whatever foolish things they may have said, or whatever foolish things they may have done. That is an axiom, certainly, but I did not just invent it: it stands in the very first article of your UDHR, and it strikes me as forming an effective bulwark against countless barbarities. An idea, a theory, an opinion, a belief, however, enjoy no such guarantee. They are destined to be scrutinized, assessed, debated, measured against empirical evidence and common sense. It thus becomes possible to judge whether they are well-founded or not; whether they are lasting or merely temporary; whether they are good, neutral, or bad. To sanctify viewpoints, dogmas, and superstitions, as you so often do, is not merely to neglect human dignity - it is to work against it.

For if there is one thing your history over the last few millennia proves, it is that bad ideas are infinitely dangerous. Your worst massacres were born from a handful of diatribes, which spread like wildfire across clouds of ignorant, frightened minds.

When a piece of writing preaches animosity, discrimination, or violence, it is disastrous to be naive enough to think that, simply because “it’s just a book”, it is harmless. Among several billion humans, there will always be a fair number in whom such exhortations find an echo, and who will turn theory into practice. A preacher of hatred is like a mafia godfather who makes his decisions by rolling dice: he kills by proxy, and through the mediation of chance, but that diminishes his criminal responsibility not one bit - quite the opposite.

What a bewildering thing it is to me, a young Tikami, that so many people who would not themselves tolerate being merely threatened with a public slap, grow so magnanimous when ideologies (I stress the plural) defame entire populations, legitimize the enslavement and rape of slaves, legalize the murder or extortion of non-believers, claim that a woman is worth (in testimony and inheritance) half of a man, justify the eternal torture of intellectual dissenters, or issue directives contradicting the most elementary medical concerns.

Selected Anecdotes

Back in the olden days of a few years ago, a fierce debate had stirred up your French society: summer-camp counselors in Gennevilliers had in fact been suspended, because they refused to eat during the day, in defiance of their employment contract’s requirements. Crowds quickly rose up against this sanction, and the Republic backed down; tacitly admitting, in doing so, that individual wishes took precedence over the common good. “Religious freedom is a fundamental freedom, and a person can under no circumstances be forbidden from practicing their religion” declared a certain CFCM (the French Council of the Muslim Faith).

Yet it seems obvious to me that no right can be conceived except in articulation with rights of a higher order, such as the Right to Life. And indeed, do you recall, my friends, why the town hall had taken it upon itself to regulate the dietary privacy of those in charge of children? Quite simply because there had been an unfortunate precedent a few years earlier: a counselor, who was fasting, had suffered a fainting spell at the wheel; injuring, in the process, two small passengers who had asked nothing of anyone.

But what scorn is heaped, in your society, upon whoever wishes to draw recommendations from empirical facts rather than huddle within ancient dogmas; upon whoever prefers biological facts to superstitions; upon whoever places the safety of children above the sanctity of beliefs. What eagerness, among your most community-minded citizens, to put employers on trial for presumed discriminatory intent, rather than look into the actual origins of health regulations. And what a lack of backbone, besides, among those who are supposed to be the guardians of the Principles of Living Together, yet desert the field the moment they see controversy looming.

This is but one example among thousands, and the intellectual currents that lead to this sort of aberration are countless. Infants who die of malnutrition because their parents eat dogmatically and scorn “conventional medicine”; modern-day Pharisees who twist their whole existence into knots so as never to have to flip a light switch on their day of rest; the credulous who are seized with a sickly fear upon crossing paths with a black cat or an unlucky number; the faithful who lock themselves into mental or physical prisons so as never to contradict their guru… Even the most harmless certainties can have dramatic consequences, as catalogued, for instance, by the English-language site what’s the harm?

The Non-Right to Non-Offense

Specific laws exist to punish insults against persons, laws which seem to enjoy broad consensus. But what is to be done when it is the simple fact of being contradicted, or of not being allowed to indulge every whim, that is experienced as an ad hominem attack? To this I answer, as a good many of your thinkers already have: it is nobody’s fundamental right not to feel offended.

Why this sudden about-face, you may ask? Would not holding one’s tongue, so as not to wound another’s convictions, be consistent with the delicacy and respect that a Tikami such as myself never tires of preaching to humans?

Well, no.

First, because, as I mentioned above, a good many theses are incompatible with the most fundamental moral rules, and lead to tragedies when they are not intelligently refuted.

Second, because unregulated ideas easily contradict one another, and will therefore keep taking offense at each other, crescendo, with no possible reconciliation; this is why, in matters of religion, the faith of some rings out as a terrible blasphemy in the ears of others, and why the greatest apostles of tolerance toward their own creed have no qualms about railing against dissident confessions.

Third, because it is no favor whatsoever to a human being to let him remain shut up in beliefs one considers wicked or false, merely to spare his feelings. Progress is born of intellectual rivalry, of controversy between divergent viewpoints, of confrontation between hypotheses - even very audacious ones - and tangible experience. It was no doubt a shock for your forebears to realize that the Earth was not at the center of the universe but out in its suburbs, and that diseases were not caused by evil spirits but by microbes; the benefits that followed, however, more than made up for those moral injuries. And it is a great pity that so many of your fellow citizens are today backsliding (creationism, flat Earth, pseudo-medicine, and so on), out of an “inner conviction” also known as obscurantism.

As with any endeavor, criticizing beliefs can only be fruitful if it is done with intelligence and good will. Producing pornographic depictions of the deities and prophets people honor, or heaping curses upon one another’s ideas, is not only dangerously close to insulting persons, but also thoroughly counter-productive. On the other hand, firmly putting one’s finger on claims that are gratuitous, absurd, or cruel can be to the intellect what defibrillators are to the heart.

It is plainly humiliating, for an infant, to watch its parents frolic about around it, when it cannot even manage to stand up; but that is the price to be paid, so that, after countless falls, it may one day do likewise. Would you dare advocate, in your societies, that adults crawl about on all fours, so as to spare their infants from feeling offended? Probably not.

But then why should you conceal, from the minds of your fellow creatures, the proven truths you hold? Such as the idea that there exists nothing less wicked on Earth than drinking a glass of plain water when one is dehydrated? That refusing a transfusion to a child suffering severe hemorrhaging is a crime nothing could ever excuse? Or that the post-mortem promises and threats of deities can only, inevitably, bind those who choose to heed them?

Do not forget, ideologues have countless real and virtual public squares at their disposal, upon which they pour out, week after week, their anathemas and their counter-truths. If humans of good sense keep silent, what more can you hope for your humanity’s future? If your “tolerance” keeps you from tackling calls to punish unbelievers and apostates, how do you expect to ever live in peace? Good will, in your world, is alas of no help whatsoever, if it is not backed by a certain sense of reality.

A Few References

Change History

  • 2016/08/12: softened the style and tone
  • 2016/09/24: minor style tweaks
Tikami in wildlifeA glimpse of the author, the Tikami